Downcasting to protocol with default values in protocol extension









up vote
0
down vote

favorite












After downcasting an array of structs, my Variables View window shows that all of the values in my struct have shifted "down" (will explain in a second). But when I print(structName), the values are fine. However, when I run an equality check on the struct, it once again behaves as though my values have shifted.



For example, I am trying to downcast Model A to ModelProtocol. var m = Model A and has the values id: "1234", name: "Cal". When I downcast, m now has the values id:"", name:"1234" .



After downcasting an array of structs, my Variables View window shows that all of the values in my struct have shifted "down" (will explain in a second). But when I print(structName), the values are fine. However, when I run an equality check on the struct, it once again behaves as though my values have shifted.



For example, I am trying to downcast Model A to ModelProtocol. var m = Model A and has the values id: "1234", name: "Cal". When I downcast, m now has the values id:"", name:"1234" .



Actual Example Below:



Models that I want to downcast:



struct PrivateSchoolModel: Decodable, SchoolProtocol 
var id: String
var name: String
var city: String
var state: String


struct PublicSchoolModel: Decodable, SchoolProtocol
var id: String
var name: String
var city: String
var state: String
var latitude: String
var longitude: String



Protocol I want to downcast to:



protocol SchoolProtocol 
var id: String get set
var name: String get set
var city: String get set
var state: String get set
var longitude: Float get set
var latitude: Float get set


extension SchoolProtocol
var longitude: Float
get return -1.0
set

var latitude: Float
get return -1.0
set




Downcasting:



guard let downcastedArr = privateSchoolArray as? [SchoolProtocol] else return 


Result (item at index 0) or originalArr:



id = "1234"
name = "Leo High School"
city = "Bellview"
state = "WA"


Result (item at index 0) of downcastedArr:



id = ""
name = "1234"
city = "Leo High School"
state = "Bellview"


But if I print(downcastArr[0]), it will show:



id = "1234"
name = "Leo High School"
city = "Bellview"
state = "WA"


But if I try originalArray[0].id == downcastArr[0].id, it returns false



My Code with the problem:



class SchoolJSONHandler 
private enum JSONFile: String
case publicSchool = "publicSchool"
case privateSchool = "privateSchool"


private lazy var privateSchoolArray = getPrivateSchools()
private lazy var publicSchoolArray = getPublicSchools()

func getSchoolArray(sorted: Bool, filtered: Bool, by stateAbbreviation: String?) -> [SchoolProtocol]
var schools = combineArrays()

if sorted
schools.sort(by: $0.name < $1.name )


if filtered
guard let abbr = stateAbbreviation else return
schools = schools.filter
return $0.state == abbr



return schools


private func combineArrays() -> [SchoolProtocol]
// EVERYTHING IS FINE IN NEXT LINE
let a = privateSchoolArray
// PROBLEM OCCURS IN NEXT 2 LINES WHEN DOWNCASTING
let b = privateSchoolArray as [SchoolProtocol]
let c = publicSchoolArray as [SchoolProtocol]
return b + c


private func getPublicSchools() -> [PublicSchoolModel]
guard let jsonData = getJSONData(from: .publicSchool) else return
guard let schools = decode(jsonData: jsonData, using: [PublicSchoolModel].self) else return
return schools


private func getPrivateSchools() -> [PrivateSchoolModel]
guard let jsonData = getJSONData(from: .privateSchool) else return
guard let schools = decode(jsonData: jsonData, using: [PrivateSchoolModel].self) else return
return schools


private func getJSONData(from resource: JSONFile) -> Data?
let url = Bundle.main.url(forResource: resource.rawValue, withExtension: "json")!
do
let jsonData = try Data(contentsOf: url)

return jsonData

catch
print(error)


return nil


private func decode<M: Decodable>(jsonData: Data, using modelType: M.Type) -> M?
do
//here dataResponse received from a network request
let decoder = JSONDecoder()
let model = try decoder.decode(modelType, from:
jsonData) //Decode JSON Response Data

return model
catch let parsingError
print("Error", parsingError)


return nil




And then it is just called in another class by schoolJSONHandler.getSchoolArray(sorted: true, filtered: true, by: "WA")










share|improve this question























  • Can you show the SchoolProtocol definition? You are casting [PrivateSchoolModel] and [PublicSchoolModel] to [SchoolProtocol] but you don't show what SchoolProtocol is. Maybe that would help in answering your question.
    – iamluisg
    Nov 10 at 18:39










  • @iamluisg Sorry, it was just named wrong in the question. Fixed
    – connorvo
    Nov 11 at 1:29














up vote
0
down vote

favorite












After downcasting an array of structs, my Variables View window shows that all of the values in my struct have shifted "down" (will explain in a second). But when I print(structName), the values are fine. However, when I run an equality check on the struct, it once again behaves as though my values have shifted.



For example, I am trying to downcast Model A to ModelProtocol. var m = Model A and has the values id: "1234", name: "Cal". When I downcast, m now has the values id:"", name:"1234" .



After downcasting an array of structs, my Variables View window shows that all of the values in my struct have shifted "down" (will explain in a second). But when I print(structName), the values are fine. However, when I run an equality check on the struct, it once again behaves as though my values have shifted.



For example, I am trying to downcast Model A to ModelProtocol. var m = Model A and has the values id: "1234", name: "Cal". When I downcast, m now has the values id:"", name:"1234" .



Actual Example Below:



Models that I want to downcast:



struct PrivateSchoolModel: Decodable, SchoolProtocol 
var id: String
var name: String
var city: String
var state: String


struct PublicSchoolModel: Decodable, SchoolProtocol
var id: String
var name: String
var city: String
var state: String
var latitude: String
var longitude: String



Protocol I want to downcast to:



protocol SchoolProtocol 
var id: String get set
var name: String get set
var city: String get set
var state: String get set
var longitude: Float get set
var latitude: Float get set


extension SchoolProtocol
var longitude: Float
get return -1.0
set

var latitude: Float
get return -1.0
set




Downcasting:



guard let downcastedArr = privateSchoolArray as? [SchoolProtocol] else return 


Result (item at index 0) or originalArr:



id = "1234"
name = "Leo High School"
city = "Bellview"
state = "WA"


Result (item at index 0) of downcastedArr:



id = ""
name = "1234"
city = "Leo High School"
state = "Bellview"


But if I print(downcastArr[0]), it will show:



id = "1234"
name = "Leo High School"
city = "Bellview"
state = "WA"


But if I try originalArray[0].id == downcastArr[0].id, it returns false



My Code with the problem:



class SchoolJSONHandler 
private enum JSONFile: String
case publicSchool = "publicSchool"
case privateSchool = "privateSchool"


private lazy var privateSchoolArray = getPrivateSchools()
private lazy var publicSchoolArray = getPublicSchools()

func getSchoolArray(sorted: Bool, filtered: Bool, by stateAbbreviation: String?) -> [SchoolProtocol]
var schools = combineArrays()

if sorted
schools.sort(by: $0.name < $1.name )


if filtered
guard let abbr = stateAbbreviation else return
schools = schools.filter
return $0.state == abbr



return schools


private func combineArrays() -> [SchoolProtocol]
// EVERYTHING IS FINE IN NEXT LINE
let a = privateSchoolArray
// PROBLEM OCCURS IN NEXT 2 LINES WHEN DOWNCASTING
let b = privateSchoolArray as [SchoolProtocol]
let c = publicSchoolArray as [SchoolProtocol]
return b + c


private func getPublicSchools() -> [PublicSchoolModel]
guard let jsonData = getJSONData(from: .publicSchool) else return
guard let schools = decode(jsonData: jsonData, using: [PublicSchoolModel].self) else return
return schools


private func getPrivateSchools() -> [PrivateSchoolModel]
guard let jsonData = getJSONData(from: .privateSchool) else return
guard let schools = decode(jsonData: jsonData, using: [PrivateSchoolModel].self) else return
return schools


private func getJSONData(from resource: JSONFile) -> Data?
let url = Bundle.main.url(forResource: resource.rawValue, withExtension: "json")!
do
let jsonData = try Data(contentsOf: url)

return jsonData

catch
print(error)


return nil


private func decode<M: Decodable>(jsonData: Data, using modelType: M.Type) -> M?
do
//here dataResponse received from a network request
let decoder = JSONDecoder()
let model = try decoder.decode(modelType, from:
jsonData) //Decode JSON Response Data

return model
catch let parsingError
print("Error", parsingError)


return nil




And then it is just called in another class by schoolJSONHandler.getSchoolArray(sorted: true, filtered: true, by: "WA")










share|improve this question























  • Can you show the SchoolProtocol definition? You are casting [PrivateSchoolModel] and [PublicSchoolModel] to [SchoolProtocol] but you don't show what SchoolProtocol is. Maybe that would help in answering your question.
    – iamluisg
    Nov 10 at 18:39










  • @iamluisg Sorry, it was just named wrong in the question. Fixed
    – connorvo
    Nov 11 at 1:29












up vote
0
down vote

favorite









up vote
0
down vote

favorite











After downcasting an array of structs, my Variables View window shows that all of the values in my struct have shifted "down" (will explain in a second). But when I print(structName), the values are fine. However, when I run an equality check on the struct, it once again behaves as though my values have shifted.



For example, I am trying to downcast Model A to ModelProtocol. var m = Model A and has the values id: "1234", name: "Cal". When I downcast, m now has the values id:"", name:"1234" .



After downcasting an array of structs, my Variables View window shows that all of the values in my struct have shifted "down" (will explain in a second). But when I print(structName), the values are fine. However, when I run an equality check on the struct, it once again behaves as though my values have shifted.



For example, I am trying to downcast Model A to ModelProtocol. var m = Model A and has the values id: "1234", name: "Cal". When I downcast, m now has the values id:"", name:"1234" .



Actual Example Below:



Models that I want to downcast:



struct PrivateSchoolModel: Decodable, SchoolProtocol 
var id: String
var name: String
var city: String
var state: String


struct PublicSchoolModel: Decodable, SchoolProtocol
var id: String
var name: String
var city: String
var state: String
var latitude: String
var longitude: String



Protocol I want to downcast to:



protocol SchoolProtocol 
var id: String get set
var name: String get set
var city: String get set
var state: String get set
var longitude: Float get set
var latitude: Float get set


extension SchoolProtocol
var longitude: Float
get return -1.0
set

var latitude: Float
get return -1.0
set




Downcasting:



guard let downcastedArr = privateSchoolArray as? [SchoolProtocol] else return 


Result (item at index 0) or originalArr:



id = "1234"
name = "Leo High School"
city = "Bellview"
state = "WA"


Result (item at index 0) of downcastedArr:



id = ""
name = "1234"
city = "Leo High School"
state = "Bellview"


But if I print(downcastArr[0]), it will show:



id = "1234"
name = "Leo High School"
city = "Bellview"
state = "WA"


But if I try originalArray[0].id == downcastArr[0].id, it returns false



My Code with the problem:



class SchoolJSONHandler 
private enum JSONFile: String
case publicSchool = "publicSchool"
case privateSchool = "privateSchool"


private lazy var privateSchoolArray = getPrivateSchools()
private lazy var publicSchoolArray = getPublicSchools()

func getSchoolArray(sorted: Bool, filtered: Bool, by stateAbbreviation: String?) -> [SchoolProtocol]
var schools = combineArrays()

if sorted
schools.sort(by: $0.name < $1.name )


if filtered
guard let abbr = stateAbbreviation else return
schools = schools.filter
return $0.state == abbr



return schools


private func combineArrays() -> [SchoolProtocol]
// EVERYTHING IS FINE IN NEXT LINE
let a = privateSchoolArray
// PROBLEM OCCURS IN NEXT 2 LINES WHEN DOWNCASTING
let b = privateSchoolArray as [SchoolProtocol]
let c = publicSchoolArray as [SchoolProtocol]
return b + c


private func getPublicSchools() -> [PublicSchoolModel]
guard let jsonData = getJSONData(from: .publicSchool) else return
guard let schools = decode(jsonData: jsonData, using: [PublicSchoolModel].self) else return
return schools


private func getPrivateSchools() -> [PrivateSchoolModel]
guard let jsonData = getJSONData(from: .privateSchool) else return
guard let schools = decode(jsonData: jsonData, using: [PrivateSchoolModel].self) else return
return schools


private func getJSONData(from resource: JSONFile) -> Data?
let url = Bundle.main.url(forResource: resource.rawValue, withExtension: "json")!
do
let jsonData = try Data(contentsOf: url)

return jsonData

catch
print(error)


return nil


private func decode<M: Decodable>(jsonData: Data, using modelType: M.Type) -> M?
do
//here dataResponse received from a network request
let decoder = JSONDecoder()
let model = try decoder.decode(modelType, from:
jsonData) //Decode JSON Response Data

return model
catch let parsingError
print("Error", parsingError)


return nil




And then it is just called in another class by schoolJSONHandler.getSchoolArray(sorted: true, filtered: true, by: "WA")










share|improve this question















After downcasting an array of structs, my Variables View window shows that all of the values in my struct have shifted "down" (will explain in a second). But when I print(structName), the values are fine. However, when I run an equality check on the struct, it once again behaves as though my values have shifted.



For example, I am trying to downcast Model A to ModelProtocol. var m = Model A and has the values id: "1234", name: "Cal". When I downcast, m now has the values id:"", name:"1234" .



After downcasting an array of structs, my Variables View window shows that all of the values in my struct have shifted "down" (will explain in a second). But when I print(structName), the values are fine. However, when I run an equality check on the struct, it once again behaves as though my values have shifted.



For example, I am trying to downcast Model A to ModelProtocol. var m = Model A and has the values id: "1234", name: "Cal". When I downcast, m now has the values id:"", name:"1234" .



Actual Example Below:



Models that I want to downcast:



struct PrivateSchoolModel: Decodable, SchoolProtocol 
var id: String
var name: String
var city: String
var state: String


struct PublicSchoolModel: Decodable, SchoolProtocol
var id: String
var name: String
var city: String
var state: String
var latitude: String
var longitude: String



Protocol I want to downcast to:



protocol SchoolProtocol 
var id: String get set
var name: String get set
var city: String get set
var state: String get set
var longitude: Float get set
var latitude: Float get set


extension SchoolProtocol
var longitude: Float
get return -1.0
set

var latitude: Float
get return -1.0
set




Downcasting:



guard let downcastedArr = privateSchoolArray as? [SchoolProtocol] else return 


Result (item at index 0) or originalArr:



id = "1234"
name = "Leo High School"
city = "Bellview"
state = "WA"


Result (item at index 0) of downcastedArr:



id = ""
name = "1234"
city = "Leo High School"
state = "Bellview"


But if I print(downcastArr[0]), it will show:



id = "1234"
name = "Leo High School"
city = "Bellview"
state = "WA"


But if I try originalArray[0].id == downcastArr[0].id, it returns false



My Code with the problem:



class SchoolJSONHandler 
private enum JSONFile: String
case publicSchool = "publicSchool"
case privateSchool = "privateSchool"


private lazy var privateSchoolArray = getPrivateSchools()
private lazy var publicSchoolArray = getPublicSchools()

func getSchoolArray(sorted: Bool, filtered: Bool, by stateAbbreviation: String?) -> [SchoolProtocol]
var schools = combineArrays()

if sorted
schools.sort(by: $0.name < $1.name )


if filtered
guard let abbr = stateAbbreviation else return
schools = schools.filter
return $0.state == abbr



return schools


private func combineArrays() -> [SchoolProtocol]
// EVERYTHING IS FINE IN NEXT LINE
let a = privateSchoolArray
// PROBLEM OCCURS IN NEXT 2 LINES WHEN DOWNCASTING
let b = privateSchoolArray as [SchoolProtocol]
let c = publicSchoolArray as [SchoolProtocol]
return b + c


private func getPublicSchools() -> [PublicSchoolModel]
guard let jsonData = getJSONData(from: .publicSchool) else return
guard let schools = decode(jsonData: jsonData, using: [PublicSchoolModel].self) else return
return schools


private func getPrivateSchools() -> [PrivateSchoolModel]
guard let jsonData = getJSONData(from: .privateSchool) else return
guard let schools = decode(jsonData: jsonData, using: [PrivateSchoolModel].self) else return
return schools


private func getJSONData(from resource: JSONFile) -> Data?
let url = Bundle.main.url(forResource: resource.rawValue, withExtension: "json")!
do
let jsonData = try Data(contentsOf: url)

return jsonData

catch
print(error)


return nil


private func decode<M: Decodable>(jsonData: Data, using modelType: M.Type) -> M?
do
//here dataResponse received from a network request
let decoder = JSONDecoder()
let model = try decoder.decode(modelType, from:
jsonData) //Decode JSON Response Data

return model
catch let parsingError
print("Error", parsingError)


return nil




And then it is just called in another class by schoolJSONHandler.getSchoolArray(sorted: true, filtered: true, by: "WA")







swift protocols downcasting






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited Nov 11 at 4:41









RLoniello

1,3952919




1,3952919










asked Nov 10 at 17:33









connorvo

889




889











  • Can you show the SchoolProtocol definition? You are casting [PrivateSchoolModel] and [PublicSchoolModel] to [SchoolProtocol] but you don't show what SchoolProtocol is. Maybe that would help in answering your question.
    – iamluisg
    Nov 10 at 18:39










  • @iamluisg Sorry, it was just named wrong in the question. Fixed
    – connorvo
    Nov 11 at 1:29
















  • Can you show the SchoolProtocol definition? You are casting [PrivateSchoolModel] and [PublicSchoolModel] to [SchoolProtocol] but you don't show what SchoolProtocol is. Maybe that would help in answering your question.
    – iamluisg
    Nov 10 at 18:39










  • @iamluisg Sorry, it was just named wrong in the question. Fixed
    – connorvo
    Nov 11 at 1:29















Can you show the SchoolProtocol definition? You are casting [PrivateSchoolModel] and [PublicSchoolModel] to [SchoolProtocol] but you don't show what SchoolProtocol is. Maybe that would help in answering your question.
– iamluisg
Nov 10 at 18:39




Can you show the SchoolProtocol definition? You are casting [PrivateSchoolModel] and [PublicSchoolModel] to [SchoolProtocol] but you don't show what SchoolProtocol is. Maybe that would help in answering your question.
– iamluisg
Nov 10 at 18:39












@iamluisg Sorry, it was just named wrong in the question. Fixed
– connorvo
Nov 11 at 1:29




@iamluisg Sorry, it was just named wrong in the question. Fixed
– connorvo
Nov 11 at 1:29

















active

oldest

votes











Your Answer






StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function ()
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function ()
StackExchange.using("snippets", function ()
StackExchange.snippets.init();
);
);
, "code-snippets");

StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "1"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);

else
createEditor();

);

function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
convertImagesToLinks: true,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: 10,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);



);













 

draft saved


draft discarded


















StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fstackoverflow.com%2fquestions%2f53241617%2fdowncasting-to-protocol-with-default-values-in-protocol-extension%23new-answer', 'question_page');

);

Post as a guest















Required, but never shown






























active

oldest

votes













active

oldest

votes









active

oldest

votes






active

oldest

votes















 

draft saved


draft discarded















































 


draft saved


draft discarded














StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fstackoverflow.com%2fquestions%2f53241617%2fdowncasting-to-protocol-with-default-values-in-protocol-extension%23new-answer', 'question_page');

);

Post as a guest















Required, but never shown





















































Required, but never shown














Required, but never shown












Required, but never shown







Required, but never shown

































Required, but never shown














Required, but never shown












Required, but never shown







Required, but never shown







這個網誌中的熱門文章

Barbados

How to read a connectionString WITH PROVIDER in .NET Core?

Node.js Script on GitHub Pages or Amazon S3